Tony Greenberg

The Technologist's Guide to Trust, Tech, Life and Society

  • Tech
    Tech
    Show More
    Top News
    otbt01 150x150 - Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    June 16, 2018
    detroit decay2 150x150 - Where’s My Flying Car … and an Efficient IT Market?
    Where’s My Flying Car … and an Efficient IT Market?
    May 25, 2023
    Big Business Keeps Buying Startups
    Save the Entrepreneur: Big Business Keeps Buying Startups, And Killing ‘Em
    May 20, 2018
    Latest News
    The Decay of Modern Day Communication and Demoralizing Lack of Accountability in Personal Messaging Which is Especially Dangerous Given all the Nearby Baboons
    March 24, 2023
    MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020
    October 23, 2021
    How CIOs Must Maximize ROI ~ Learn This Or Find A New Role – Joe Weinman
    October 20, 2017
    10 Magic Questions to Make Your Project Go Right- How to Kick Ass by Kicking Assumptions
    October 20, 2017
  • Business
    Business
    Show More
    Top News
    otbt01 150x150 - Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    June 16, 2018
    Simplify your life
    From Dr. Bronner’s to Pressure Cookers
    May 25, 2023
    happyearthday 150x150 - The Tug of War – Ethical vs. Economic Decisions
    The Tug of War – Ethical vs. Economic Decisions
    May 25, 2023
    Latest News
    The Decay of Modern Day Communication and Demoralizing Lack of Accountability in Personal Messaging Which is Especially Dangerous Given all the Nearby Baboons
    March 24, 2023
    Hiding Fees in the Transparent Age is Just Bad Business
    May 25, 2023
    More Ignorance or Indignance in the Wake of Covid?
    October 23, 2021
    MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020
    October 23, 2021
  • Tony
    Tony
    Show More
    Top News
    Relationships 150x150 - The Arithmetic of Relationships > What’s Our Mutual Net Profit?
    The Arithmetic of Relationships > What’s Our Mutual Net Profit?
    September 20, 2021
    high hells 150x150 - HIGH HELLS - The Demise of Powerful Femininity
    HIGH HELLS – The Demise of Powerful Femininity
    October 18, 2017
    connect 2777620 1920 150x150 - Mastering Human and Business Development
    Mastering Human and Business Development
    May 25, 2023
    Latest News
    Protected: 💫 🎈 **Ode to a Soiree of Spiritual Sojourn** 🎈
    September 26, 2023
    Lodge Bread Stuck In Suck-Cess with No Customer Service As Good as Their Bread
    September 22, 2023
    Energy as Impact
    August 16, 2023
    India, My Virtual Soul & Home
    June 9, 2023
  • Tony Greenberg | Chaos Conductor & Charming Insultant
Reading: Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?
Share
Aa

Tony Greenberg

The Technologist's Guide to Trust, Tech, Life and Society

Aa
  • Tech
  • Business
  • Tony
  • Tony Greenberg | Chaos Conductor & Charming Insultant
  • Tech
  • Business
  • Tony
  • Tony Greenberg | Chaos Conductor & Charming Insultant
Follow US
Tony Greenberg > Blog > Business > Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?
Business

Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?

Tony Greenberg
Last updated: 2017/12/15 at 6:59 AM
Tony Greenberg
Share
6 Min Read
Price Fixing6 - Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?
SHARE

Price Fixing - Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?

In the wake of hurricanes, as the deluge recedes, regulators see a rising flood of complaints about price gouging for necessities such as water and gas. And despite contrary opinions from some economists, 34 states have anti-gouging laws on the books. Even if there’s no law, people expect a retailer to feel bad about charging a different price to someone in a situation of desperate scarcity in a way that they don’t feel bad about a Black Friday sale, senior or student discount, coupons, and other ways to practice subtler price discrimination. But does the same thing apply when a business is 100% reliant on one technology provider?

We’ve always known that there is price discrimination in technology services. Larger customers or those with a marketable brand get a scale discount. Those who shop around, negotiate, and hire advisors, do better than those that just go with a known brand and trust the sales guy when he says he’s cutting his own throat to get this special deal. Anchor tenants that put their trust in a new service or co-lo are rewarded relative to later adopters; as are those who commit for a longer term.

There are also times when the scale, time, deal term, and all other facets of the deal are the same, but the prices are very different based on one thing and one thing only – whether the customer is “captive” and cannot switch to another service. Maybe the more egalitarian blockchain networks will have better governance and value exchange in the coming age of decentralization.

Next generation networks like EOS and Ripple may more fairly change for their services. While everyone has the right to make a profit, all boats should somewhat rise to stay healthy. Net Neutrality does the opposite and will persecute our access to certain informations at certain qualities. That’s why anti monopoly laws are important. In an extreme adverse example, the price of epipens led to the CEO going to prison.

Price Fixing2 - Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT?

Sometimes it’s due to a strategic relationship; organizational knowledge at the provider that’s hard to transfer; custom code to adapt to a specific CDN, etc. – difficult but not impossible to overcome obstacles. But a recent survey we did on low latency hosting (still open if you’re interested in participating and getting an aggregate of the results) showed that the gap is perhaps most glaring when the constraint is physics – latency constrained by the speed of light.

When a financial services client is in a specific co-lo building or campus because its usage scenario is low latency trading, its pricing can be 34%-75% higher than another financial services firm that’s buying the same amount in the exact same location but doesn’t care about those cross-connects as much; to say nothing of a client in online retail that just picked it for convenience to their offices. Same size, same timing, same skilled sourcing professionals. The only difference is captivity. But is that gouging?

Of course there are layers of salesmanship to help hosting provider execs avoid facing the question – and the lack of transparency in non-cloud IT infrastructure markets can allow them to get away with it. Just like some politicians focus on the source of the leak rather than the wrongdoing the leak exposed, there is brandishing of NDAs and demands to know sources when we expose the difference. But what if the secret is out? Is there a reasonable defense to say “yes, we charge you 50% more because you can’t go anywhere; just say thanks we’re not going the Martin Shkreli route and jacking it up by a factor of 56x”?

To some, the reasonable answer is in the concept of value-based pricing (as opposed to effort-based pricing) – if a low latency financial hub hosting service is more critical to a business function, it deserves a higher reward than the same space being used as just another co-lo. After all, we at RampRate charge more for saving someone $10M than for saving $1M even though our effort can often be similar. But still, no buyer we talk to is convinced that an identical service to an identical customer should be priced differently just based on their ability to switch.

So what do you think? Is price discrimination based on lack of alternatives justifiable? Would you support it openly, just as the economists opposing anti-price gouging laws do? Or do you think it’s an unethical practice that will die out if it comes out of the shadows?

You Might Also Like

The Decay of Modern Day Communication and Demoralizing Lack of Accountability in Personal Messaging Which is Especially Dangerous Given all the Nearby Baboons

Hiding Fees in the Transparent Age is Just Bad Business

More Ignorance or Indignance in the Wake of Covid?

MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020

From Supply Chain to the Blockchain: Heal the Body, Mind, & Earth

TAGGED: IT buyers

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
[mc4wp_form]
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Tony Greenberg December 15, 2017 December 15, 2017
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Share
By Tony Greenberg
Follow:
I speed through life building relationships, businesses and finding extraordinary people and contemplating the curious decisions they make. The premise of this space is to expose the bridges and chasms of trust, truth and bias that I encounter daily.
Previous Article happyearthday 150x150 - Is There Such a Thing as Price Gouging and Price Fixing in IT? The Tug of War – Ethical vs. Economic Decisions
Next Article Perspective on Blockchain A Historical Perspective on Blockchain
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected:

Business InsiderHuffington PostRSSTony on TwitterTony on FacebookRampRate on FacebookTony on LinkedIn

Business Insider

Huffington Post

RSS

Twitter

Facebook

Linkedin

Forbes

Latest News

Protected: 💫 🎈 **Ode to a Soiree of Spiritual Sojourn** 🎈
Tony September 26, 2023
Lodge Bread Stuck In Suck-Cess with No Customer Service As Good as Their Bread
Tony September 22, 2023
unnamed 150x150 - Energy as Impact
Energy as Impact
Tony August 15, 2023
pexels jeswin thomas 1007426 150x150 - India, My Virtual Soul & Home
India, My Virtual Soul & Home
Tony June 9, 2023

Copyright ©2000 - 2023. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?