Tony Greenberg

The Technologist's Guide to Trust, Tech, Life and Society

  • Tech
    Tech
    Show More
    Top News
    customer demand
    Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    December 17, 2024
    detroit decay
    Where’s My Flying Car … and an Efficient IT Market?
    December 17, 2024
    Big Business Keeps Buying Startups
    Save the Entrepreneur: Big Business Keeps Buying Startups, And Killing ‘Em
    December 17, 2024
    Latest News
    The Decay of Modern Day Communication & Demoralizing Lack of Accountability in Personal Messaging Which is Especially Dangerous Given all the Nearby Baboons
    December 2, 2024
    MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020
    December 10, 2024
    How CIOs Must Maximize ROI ~ Learn This Or Find A New Role – Joe Weinman
    December 12, 2024
    10 Magic Questions to Make Your Project Go Right- How to Kick Ass by Kicking Assumptions
    December 12, 2024
  • Business
    Business
    Show More
    Top News
    customer demand
    Why Good Service Is All About Trust
    December 17, 2024
    Simplify your life
    From Dr. Bronner’s to Pressure Cookers
    December 17, 2024
    The Tug of War – Ethical vs. Economic Decisions
    December 12, 2024
    Latest News
    The Decay of Modern Day Communication & Demoralizing Lack of Accountability in Personal Messaging Which is Especially Dangerous Given all the Nearby Baboons
    December 2, 2024
    Hiding Fees & Tips in the Transparent Age is Just Bad Business
    February 21, 2025
    More Ignorance or Indignance in the Wake of Covid-19?
    February 21, 2025
    MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020
    December 10, 2024
  • Tony
    Tony
    Show More
    Top News
    The Arithmetic of Relationships > What’s Our Mutual Net Profit?
    January 26, 2025
    Mastering Human and Business Development
    December 9, 2024
    HIGH HELLS – The Demise of Powerful Femininity
    December 12, 2024
    Latest News
    Trap: How DMN8 Gym Became A Poster Child for Fitness Fraud
    May 16, 2025
    DMN8 The Most Beautiful (Crooked) Gym in the World?
    May 16, 2025
    Mastering BD: The Art of the No That Opens the Real Door
    March 22, 2025
    Productivity Apps That Rocked My World in 2024: Secrets of a Workflow Wizard
    February 25, 2025
  • TonyG: Transforming Industries and Perceptions
Reading: Would You Hire Someone Who Led a Rebellion?
Share
Aa

Tony Greenberg

The Technologist's Guide to Trust, Tech, Life and Society

Aa
  • Tech
  • Business
  • Tony
  • TonyG: Transforming Industries and Perceptions
  • Tech
  • Business
  • Tony
  • TonyG: Transforming Industries and Perceptions
Follow US
Tony Greenberg > Blog > Featured > Would You Hire Someone Who Led a Rebellion?
Featured

Would You Hire Someone Who Led a Rebellion?

Alex Veytsel
Last updated: 2024/12/12 at 4:19 AM
Alex Veytsel
Share
17 Min Read
SHARE

Leadership of a rebellion

Contents
A Bit of HistoryThe Co-opting of LeadershipDefining the Rebel LeaderRebellion as a Tool for SuccessWhen and How to RebelWhy Rebel?Interviewing a Rebel

Leadership of a rebellionTop X lists are generally clickbait tripe. But we need people, I need to interview them, so “Top 5 Interview Questions” sounds worth clicking. And then I read this: When I asked “tell me about something you’ve led,” one of the candidates paused and then answered, “I once led a revolt against management in a manufacturing company I worked for.” Wrong answer.

No. It’s the right answer. Not the only right answer, but it may just be the best answer.

Just like you you can only be brave when you’re afraid, you can only show leadership when following you carries a risk or sacrifice. Otherwise, you’re just front-running a trend.

The term “leadership” has been co-opted in the business world. It used to have real meaning that implied courage, sacrifice, and dedication. Now it is just another dot on the corporate bullshit bingo card. Business people now actually think leadership is about being popular and liked; not offending anyone in power and following the rules, to the point that leading a rebellion disqualifies you from a leadership role with whatever this Procurious outfit is.

And that’s what’s broken in business. We need more rebels in leadership roles. We need people to stand up and say “the king is naked” every once in a while. We need someone to tell the CEO he’s driving the company car off a cliff and put their professional life on the line for the right cause, whether it’s ethics or company direction. Instead we get a toxic mix of conformists and backstabbers – those who follow the company line even if they don’t believe in it, and those that cheer the loudest in support only to undermine the plan behind the scenes.

Well, if that’s what you want, you can keep the yes-people. And send me your rebel candidates. Maybe there’s a place for them here at RampRate.

A Bit of History

Who are the top leaders we think of in the history of the US? In some order, the top 3 are near-universally listed as the following — rebellious, polarizing, and rule-breaking — presidents:

  • George Washington led a rebellion.
  • Abraham Lincoln was so unpopular, half the states left the union.
  • FDR offended all the moneyed interests and pushed more unconstitutional laws than any other president (including trying to pack the Supreme Court to allow them to go through).

You don’t have to agree with the list to recognize the leadership qualities.

If your preference leans towards Ronald Reagan instead of FDR, he tried to lead a party revolt against a sitting president in 1976. So did Teddy Roosevelt, another fixture in the top 3 on historian lists, not to mention on Mount Rushmore.

Heck, even if you’re not a fan of Lincoln and talk about the “war of northern aggression,” then your heroes are rebels too.

The Co-opting of Leadership

Over time, the term leadership, at least in the business world, has been co-opted by something that passively or actively writes rebellious acts out of the picture. Rather, leadership is viewed as fostering consensus, implementing “best practices,” and otherwise doing the Dale Carnegie thing – making friends and influencing people.  A recent Forbes summary of leadership definitions lands on this after going through several other unsatisfactory variants from industry luminaries: Leadership is a process of social influence, which maximizes the efforts of others, towards the achievement of a goal.

This is not cherrypicked. As of today, this is among the top results on Google and the summary definition used in an 9,000+ word Wikipedia article on leadership. Out of everything that was written from Plato onwards through “leadership studies” programs in MBA schools; out of 96 citations listed in the same article, this bland platitude is where we landed as a group. And a sad thing this is:

  • Note the inherent lack of conflict or obstacles in this definition. Everyone gets in a circle and sings Kumbaya, and the one that can get everyone to sing loudest is the leader.
  • There’s no reference to actually achieving a result either – so you don’t even have to get anyone to sing louder – just to “maximize their effort.”
  • Also, there’s no mention of the goal being something worthwhile. Getting the team to paddle towards the 1000-foot waterfall is as good as getting them to paddle to shore.
  • Maybe we’re in a new postmodern world where there’s no objectively good goals. But there isn’t even a reference to the “leader” actually believing in the goal he’s leading towards.

You know what you just defined? An amoral manipulator. That’s your perfect business leader according to Forbes. And practice is not too far from theory. A recent study indicated that 1 of every 25 business leaders is a psychopath.  And if anything, I would say that’s a conservative number.

Anyone who’s worked for a large company has seen leadership positions taken by empty suits with no appreciable talent except for making rousing speeches that no one, least of all the speaker, actually believes. For instance, they have no moral compass or qualms about the hypocrisy of saying “our people are our most important asset” even as they lay off half their staff. They are careful to follow the party line, especially when they’re undermining it behind the scenes. But one thing they never get caught in is an open rebellion.

These are the leaders we get in the business world – and if our definition is as above, they are the leaders we deserve.

Defining the Rebel Leader

So how do we change the definition of leadership to define George Washington in and Patrick Bateman out? Here’s my shot:

  • A leader inspires himself and others to take risks and make sacrifices to reach a shared success.

Let’s decompose this a bit:

  • Inspires himself: A hypocrite is not a leader. Neither is a general sending waves of soldiers against an impregnable position. But someone who pledges his life, fortune, and sacred honour to the cause is a leader.
  • Inspires others: Unquestionably, a leader needs followers. But there’s no need for active “social influence” or manipulation. Leading by example also works, as long as it’s inspirational.
  • Take risks and make sacrifices: Selling something at no cost does not make you a good salesman. Similarly, leading someone in a direction that does not differ materially from where they would go based on their self-interest does not make you a good leader.
  • Shared success: A good leader does not discard followers as soon as they’re no longer useful. He does not take all the credit. That’s what makes him better than an amoral manipulator.

Rebellion is not in the definition directly. With apologies to the ghost of James Dean, following a rebel without a cause is not the best of ideas. But when the obstacle to shared success within an organization is unreasonable authority, there is no choice for a leader, but to rebel.  It may not be the first resort – you can reason, plead, bargain, whatever the case may be. But when those in command are unswerving in following a course that will lead your team away from shared success, rebellion is the only choice.

Rebellion as a Tool for Success

So who am I to talk about leadership? I don’t lead a school of leadership studies. I didn’t even go to one. I’m not a general or a CEO. But I think I’ve been fortunate to inspire a few people in my life. And I’m not alone. For example, one of the things that took PayPal to a top firm was fostering a culture of dissent. Encouraging open disagreement has been recognized by Harvard Business School as a marker of success. Scot Hanley posted a good overview of rebellion in leadership through the centuries.

When and How to Rebel

Not all rebellions are positive. There are good reasons to rebel and bad ones – and likewise positive and negative paths to achieving the change you are seeking. These may vary based on your own moral compass. For example, for me, sins of commission (e.g. lying to someone) are different than sins of omission (e.g. not speaking up when you hear a colleague blatantly lying). For others, they are equivalent. But I think reflecting on the seriousness of the act of rebellion will lead you to the right decision for you – as it did for me in the matrix below:

While I think the above are good universal guidelines, there are also ones that I realize are deeply personal. For instance, I consider hypocrisy and double standards to be intolerable and would not want to be part of an organization that has “quo licet Jovi, non licet bovi” as a motto. But for others, a hierarchy that rewards executives with flexible hours while firing a clerk for being 2 minutes late may be ok. I believe in justice – rewarding those that contributed to the company success with the best pay. Others believe in market pricing – you don’t earn what you deserve, but what you negotiate. I believe in common sense – if no one reads a report, it’s no failure to stop writing it. Others believe in properly following proper protocols and eliminating judgment calls in favor of process.

In terms of means, positive leadership of a rebellion is a last resort. Before you rebel, you cajole, prove, plead, bargain. Defiance is a last step. And when that step is taken, it’s a lot like civil disobedience. You don’t hide from the consequences. You go in fully realizing that your views may cost you career advancement, your job, or even your career in your chosen industry if you have a particularly vindictive boss. And you don’t hide the consequences from the people that follow you into rebellion. Your opposition is not undermining an idea or project behind the scenes – it is direct refusal to participate in or endorse insane or unethical courses of action. In other words, it’s insubordination. And insubordination is a firing offense, so be ready to be fired.

Why Rebel?

In the face of that, why rebel? Why risk it all and ask others to do so as well? Because life is too short to be a hypocrite. Because no amount of money is enough to buy back your soul. Because “I was just following orders” is no excuse. And because there is a different result that you can get. Because others around you may think the same thing you are thinking but be too afraid of not conforming to tell the emperor he has no clothes.[i]  And last, but by no means least, because you might just win.

Like Kierkegaard’s knight of infinite resignation, you go into a rebellion expecting to fail. After all, if your management was unreasonable enough to ignore the cajoling, pleading, and bargaining phases, then they have to be evil and/or delusional, right? But in spite of all of that, if you rebel, you believe deep down that they’re not beyond redemption – that somewhere is still the person that you were excited to partner with when they hired you – the one that you shared a drink with over a shared success or failure. And sometimes, putting yourself out there and saying “I believe in this strongly enough to put my job on the line” gets them back to being that person.

Then again, that assumes there’s a human being involved. If your opponent is a corporate machine, might as well pack your things and work for a small business next time.

[i] Maybe they remember this great quote from Terry Pratchett: Then you have The Story of the Emperor Who Had No Clothes.

But if you knew a bit more, it would be The Story of the Boy Who Got a Well-Deserved Thrashing from His Dad for Being Rude to Royalty, and Was Locked Up. Or The Story of the Whole Crowd Who Were Rounded Up by the Guards and Told ‘This Didn’t Happen, Okay? Does Anyone Want to Argue?’ Or it could be a story of how a whole kingdom suddenly saw the benefits of the ‘new clothes’, and developed an enthusiasm for healthy sports* in a lively and refreshing atmosphere which got many new adherents every year, and led to a recession caused by the collapse of the conventional clothing industry. It could even be a story about The Great Pneumonia Epidemic of ’09. It all depends on how much you know.

Interviewing a Rebel

So suppose you asked the question of “what have you led” and someone told you they led a rebellion. I don’t know about you, but I’d be full of questions:

  • What was the impetus?
  • What did you try before rebelling?
  • How did you do it?
  • Who supported you?
  • What was the outcome?

And yes, some answers to that would be bad. Selfish reasons for rebelling. Backroom intrigues. Lack of support. But I’d at least be curious. Wouldn’t you? And maybe I’d hire that rebel after all.

Share this:

  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window) Pocket
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Related

You Might Also Like

POWERING PURPOSE-DRIVEN INNOVATION

Innovative Thinking with Tony Greenberg – The Scale Up Show with Ryan Staley 2024

Forward Health is a sideway step at best

More Ignorance or Indignance in the Wake of Covid-19?

MARC ANDREESSEN REBUTTAL 2020

TAGGED: leadership

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
[mc4wp_form]
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article How fast-growth companies are most likely to fall Part 3
Next Article The Tug of War – Ethical vs. Economic Decisions
Leave a comment Leave a comment

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected:

Business InsiderHuffington PostRSSTony on TwitterTony on FacebookRampRate on FacebookTony on LinkedIn

Business Insider

Huffington Post

RSS

Twitter

Facebook

Linkedin

Forbes

Latest News

Trap: How DMN8 Gym Became A Poster Child for Fitness Fraud
Tony May 16, 2025
DMN8 The Most Beautiful (Crooked) Gym in the World?
Tony May 16, 2025
Mastering BD: The Art of the No That Opens the Real Door
Tony March 22, 2025
Productivity Apps That Rocked My World in 2024: Secrets of a Workflow Wizard
Tony December 11, 2024

Copyright ©2000 - 2024. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?