The Gatekeepers
A ranked guide to US mezcal importers. Who's bringing the real stuff, and who's flooding the market with industrial swill and celebrity cash-grabs.
Why this matters: The importer you buy from determines whether your money supports traditional mezcalero families or corporate shareholders. The Guardians work directly with producers, pay fair prices, and educate consumers. The Wall of Shame prioritizes marketing over quality and often uses additives or industrial methods.
THE GUARDIANS
These importers are the true champions of mezcal culture. They prioritize authenticity, direct relationships with mezcaleros, and education over profit.
PM Spirits
Founded by Nicolas Palazzi
No additives, single-cask bottlings, true essence of origins. Each bottle tells a story of its origin, the craft, and the passion of its makers.
Brands
Del Maguey Single Village Mezcal
Founded by Ron Cooper (1995)
The pioneer who started it all. Single-village sourcing, direct producer relationships, education-first approach. Ron Cooper brought mezcal to America and changed everything.
Brands
Contact
Bad Hombre Imports
Founded by Fred Sanchez (2014)
Education-first approach, community impact focus. Works exclusively with small, independent brands that have positive impact on their communities. Specializes in on-premise customers.
Brands
Contact
Baron François
Est. 1982
Bridging tradition and modernity since 1982. Artisanal mezcals that blend traditional production methods with innovative approaches while respecting Mexico's distilling heritage.
Brands
Contact
Erstwhile Mezcal
Direct relationships with producers, transparency in sourcing, commitment to preserving traditional methods and supporting mezcalero families.
Brands
Contact
Noble Coyote
Artisanal mezcal handcrafted in Oaxaca with focus on traditional methods and authentic expression of terroir.
Brands
SOLID CHOICES
Reputable importers with good portfolios. They bring quality products to market with reasonable business practices.
Mara Imports
Founded by Maricela Martinez (2017)
Family-owned with 80+ years combined industry experience. Focus on authenticity, heritage, and long-term relationships with producers.
Brands
Contact
Pacific Edge Wine & Spirits
Innovative approach with exclusive brand experiences. Avoids brand overlap to provide distinctive portfolio for on-premise partners.
Brands
Contact
Double Eagle Imports
Focus on artisanal promotion through storytelling, creative marketing, and retail activations. Emphasizes high-quality sipping tequilas.
Brands
Contact
Lizarraga Company
Imports from Durango, Oaxaca, Chihuahua, and Guanajuato. Mezcal for everyone, everywhere.
Brands
Contact
COMMERCIAL
Mass-market focused importers. Not necessarily bad, but prioritize volume and mainstream appeal over artisanal craft.
Freshie Imports
Focus on organic certification and mainstream appeal. Solar-powered, carbon-neutral production.
Brands
WALL OF SHAME
These importers bring products that undermine mezcal culture through industrial methods, additives, celebrity marketing, or outright deception.
Diageo
Massive corporate conglomerate prioritizing volume over authenticity.
Casamigos lawsuit alleged only 33% agave content. Industrial production methods. Celebrity marketing over substance.
Brands
Proximo Spirits
Industrial scale production with mainstream focus.
Mass production, diffuser methods suspected, prioritizes volume over craft.
Brands
Celebrity Brand Distributors
Celebrity names over mezcal quality.
Dos Hombres: Lowest rated on mezcalreviews.com. 818: Red flag celebrity brand. These prioritize marketing spend over liquid quality.
Brands
Clase Azul Importers
Beautiful bottles, questionable contents.
Known for additives including vanilla, artificial sweeteners, glycerin, and caramel coloring. The bottle costs more than the liquid inside.
Brands
Industrial Mezcal Importers
Mass production for uninformed consumers.
Worm gimmicks, industrial production, diffuser methods. These brands set mezcal back decades and perpetuate stereotypes.
Brands
How to Use This Guide
For Consumers
Check who imports the mezcal before you buy. If it comes from a Guardian, you're supporting traditional production and fair trade. If it's from the Wall of Shame, your money goes to marketing departments and corporate profits.
For Bars & Restaurants
Partner with Guardian importers for your mezcal program. They offer education, staff training, and authentic stories that elevate your menu. PM Spirits and Bad Hombre specialize in on-premise relationships.